2025/26 Season
Player Ratings
Independent fan project. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Everton FC, the Premier League, or any official body. Read more
Squad Avg Rating
6.19
Top Scorer
Beto · 9
Top Assists
Garner · 7
Starting XI
Formation: 4 - 2 - 3 - 1
Fan-made end of season player ratings
Click any player below to see their rating, key stats, and the reasons behind their score, all through the eyes of a fellow Blue. Vote Keep or Sell on each.
Bench
11 players
Your Verdict
Who stays and who goes
Cast your votes on each player above to build your verdict.
You say STAY
You haven't picked anyone to stay yet.
You say GO
You haven't picked anyone to go yet.
Fan Verdict
What all fans say
No votes yet. Cast yours above to shape the verdict.
Fans say KEEP
No clear keepers yet.
Fans say SELL
No-one's on the chopping block yet.